This month, our innovators tackled big seasonal changes and holiday planning, and how to navigate those shifts without losing focus, energy, or team morale.
From creative community events that drive traffic to retention strategies that keep great employees through the ups and downs, October’s Masterminds were all about balance. Innovators shared practical ways to prepare their stores and staff for the holidays, from fine-tuning B2B systems and refreshing social media strategies, to calculating pay raises, bonuses, and even when to start Christmas setup.
The message was clear: the stores that thrive during the holidays aren’t the ones that do it all. They’re the ones that plan ahead, lead well, and execute intentionally. Let’s dig in!
Table of Contents:
B2B Mastermind Takeaways:
Takeaway #1: Building a Solid List is the First Step Toward a Holistic B2B Program
Innovators revisited one of the most essential B2B foundations: list-building. A strong customer list doesn’t just drive short-term sales. It creates a pipeline for future growth. Those investing in better list management, primarily the entering of prospect information into a CRM, will have an easier time setting up consistent outreach and tracking relationships for the life of the business.
Takeaway #2: AceNet Offers a “CRM Lite” that Lacks List-Building Features
As you Ace dealers already know, while AceNet offers useful sales tools, many agreed it falls short when it comes to customer relationship management. Innovators compared its capabilities to true CRMs like HubSpot, which can better track customer interactions, automate reminders, and provide visibility into sales opportunities.
Takeaway #3: It Takes About 15 Touchpoints to Close a Sale. HubSpot Can Help You Keep Track.
Consistency, not coincidence, closes deals. Innovators shared that the most successful accounts are often the result of 10-15 meaningful touchpoints over time. Relying on a salesperson to make all 15 touchpoints is a mistake. Getting your marketing and sales folks on the same page, leveraging a revenue strategy together, is the key to success.
Using a CRM like HubSpot makes that process easier to manage, ensuring that nothing slips through the cracks and every contact is followed up with.
Takeaway #4: Don’t Even Think About Bringing Up Sales in the First 30 Seconds of a Conversation
A newer B2B Lead asked for advice on building customer relationships. Innovators agreed that early outreach should focus on connection, not sales. Whether it’s a quick visit, a call, or a casual check-in, the first few minutes are about listening and showing up — not pitching.
Takeaway #5: Property Managers are a Goldmine for B2B Sales
One of the biggest untapped opportunities discussed was property management. Although it’s on top of the list for most trainings, there aren’t a lot of long-term, nurturing strategies for our B2B folks to use. Innovators pointed out that property managers often oversee dozens of units, making them repeat customers for everything from maintenance supplies to seasonal products.
One team’s current win: working on snowblower deals for property managers at ~$4K each. With the right outreach, one contact can turn into a long-term, high-volume partnership.
Helpful Resources for B2B
- HubSpot’s Free CRM
- Switch: A book on creating behavioral change when people on your team aren’t inspired or aligned!
- How to Join a Zoom Meeting
- AI Sales Platform for B2B
Marketing Mastermind Takeaways:
Takeaway #1: Pumpkin Painting Is the Clear Winner Over Pumpkin Carving Stations
Innovators agreed that pumpkin painting beats carving on every front. It’s safer, less messy, and easier to run in-store.
One innovator shared that carving stations “were huge here” in past years, but now require far more cleanup and supervision than they’re worth.
Painting events, on the other hand, drew strong family participation and kept traffic up without the extra labor burden. All you need is some paint pens, a tablecloth, and a few bags of mini pumpkins from your local market.
Takeaway #2: How One Innovator Displayed 500 Christmas Trees So That 99% Sold
A Florida-based innovator shared their process for setting up a tree lot that sold all but five of their 500 trees. The layout included an 80-foot run that held 200 trees at a time, built with custom two-by-four stands for stability. They focused exclusively on 8-9-foot trees after identifying that smaller sizes didn’t sell in their market.
Adding carryout service and an on-site netting baler completed the experience — turning their parking lot into what one attendee called a “winter wonderland” that customers look forward to each year.
Takeaway #3: When’s the Best Time to Start Christmas Setup? Our Innovators Are Overlapping Seasons.
Timing for holiday transitions sparked lively debate. Most stores reported setting up Christmas displays by mid-October, with one innovator starting as early as October 1 to maximize sales and reduce the bottleneck between Halloween and Christmas.
Another shared that they now put Halloween upfront near impulse items and transition Christmas décor toward the back, creating natural overlap and extending both categories’ shelf life.
Takeaway #4: Social Media Usage Goes up 73% During the Holidays: Now is the Time to Boost Social Presence!
Innovators discussed how social platforms see major engagement spikes during November and December. The takeaway: don’t slow down your posting cadence. Increase frequency, boost your top-performing posts, and double down on content that highlights people and communities. That’s what customers want to see this time of year.
Takeaway #5: Holiday Idea Hub: Hot Cocoa Stations, Santa Photos, Santa Letters, Toy Catalogs, Scavenger Hunts, & Grinch-Approved Stickers
Innovators compared holiday traditions that work: one store hosted a hot cocoa station without needing a food permit by simply selling cups and offering the cocoa for free. Others invested in community “Santa photo” stations with consistent backdrops and even shared Santas across small towns to build familiarity and reduce costs.
Simple touches like this not only drew families in but generated easily shareable content for social. Scroll down for examples from our innovators!
Takeaway #6: Younger Generations are More Likely to Buy Online: Can We Capture Them with the Promise of Gift-Wrapping?
With nearly half of Gen Z’s shopping happening online during the holidays, innovators discussed ways to make in-store shopping feel just as convenient. One standout idea: promote a gift-wrapping service as a value-add to pull in younger, time-strapped customers.
This might be especially appealing for shoppers buying gifts for others in their household, who don’t want product boxes showing up at their door and spoiling the surprise.
Helpful Resources for Marketers
- November Marketing Budget Webinar
- Holiday Tradition Inspiration:
General Managers Mastermind Takeaways:
Takeaway #1: Have You Done the Math on the Cost of Turnover? Hint: It’s a Lot.
Turnover was called out as one of the most expensive hidden costs heading into the holiday season. One GM calculated the average loss at over $4,000 per associate once hiring, training, and lost productivity were factored in. The message was clear: investing in retention saves money in the long run.
Resource Spotlight: This conversation echoed lessons from Good to Great by Jim Collins — particularly the idea of “getting the right people on the bus.” If you’re rethinking your team structure heading into 2026, this book is worth revisiting.
Takeaway #2: Only Giving Bonuses to Certain Departments? Consider a Commission Instead
The group discussed how unbalanced holiday bonuses can hurt culture. For instance, if a store’s garden center brings in the bulk of seasonal sales, those employees may get bonuses while others don’t. This setup can unintentionally create frustration among the wider team.
One innovator shared a transparent bonus spreadsheet that broke down qualifications by department and tenure, helping staff understand how payouts were calculated. Another suggested reframing department-specific bonuses as commissions, since those rewards are tied directly to sales, and even switching to quarterly payouts to help manage cash flow.
Takeaway #3: Self Check-Out Isn’t the Way to Go When Customer Service is Your Differentiator
While some chains are experimenting with automation, innovators reaffirmed that personal service is what sets local stores apart. As one GM put it, “Our differentiator is customer service.” Instead of self-checkout, discussions centered on labor optimization, cross-training, and improving efficiency while keeping customer touchpoints human.
Takeaway #4: How One Innovator Incentivizes with Pay Raises Throughout the Training Process
Incremental raises tied to training milestones stood out as a simple but powerful retention strategy. Innovators shared that connecting pay bumps to measurable skills not only reduced turnover but also helped new hires see a clear growth path. It’s a model designed to keep employees engaged from day one and is especially crucial during the holidays when new seasonal staff need quick wins.
Takeaway #5: Could Your Employees Earn More at McDonald’s?
Several GMs raised the concern that fast-food jobs in their regions now pay $18–$20/hour, higher than entry-level wages in hardware retail. The consensus: while matching pay isn’t always possible, stores can compete through culture, recognition, and flexibility. Our innovators didn’t have time to cover everything they wanted about payroll issues, so we’ll continue this conversation next month!
Helpful Resources for GMs
- November Marketing Budget Webinar
- Good to Great
- Bonus Spreadsheet Example:
Join Us On November 19th for Our Next Mastermind
For November, we’ll have three groups that meet: B2B, Marketing, and GMs.
In the B2B Mastermind, we’ll map out Annual Growth Planning + Customer Touchpoints — we’ll dig into each touch point a B2B salesperson and marketer does to set up, nurture, and close a deal.
In the Marketing Mastermind, we’re diving into Measuring Marketing ROI: From Circulars to Digital, What to Axe and What to Max. You’ll see how to track results across channels, identify which campaigns are actually driving sales, and cut what’s not working before budgets renew.
And in the General Managers Mastermind, we’ll tackle Setting Your 2026 Budget + Payroll Challenges w/ Rising Wages. Expect practical insights on how to budget for pay increases, balance incentives, and plan for sustainable staffing through the new year.
Need help signing up? Join here!
Are You On Board?
Does the idea of a monthly meet-up with other retail hardware stores sound valuable? Would you like to share resources, ask questions, and participate with your peers on-demand through an exclusive Slack channel?
Email us at hello@hardwareinnovators.com to get access to the Slack Channel! The best part? It’s 100% free and puts you in touch with hardware store general managers, marketers, and B2B reps to ask questions and get immediate feedback from what worked at other hardware stores!